Yes, this actually happened.
A well-known Indian news publisher wrote and published a proper, original article.
Google crawled it… and then decided the original version exists on a porn site.
Result?
Google gave credit to the porn site, not the publisher.
That’s called “canonical” in Google terms – the version it prefers to show and rank.

Just imagine that.
A real newsroom team worked hard – reporting, writing, editing, publishing.
But when Google’s systems scanned the web, they got confused.
And the scraper or porn site got all the credit.
This isn’t just a small technical issue.
It’s the exact opposite of what Google keeps preaching about trust, E-E-A-T, and helpful content.
What really happened?
- A porn site copied the news article (either fully or partially)
- Google crawled both the porn site and the original
- Instead of choosing the publisher, Google thought the porn site was the “main source”
- The publisher’s article was marked as duplicate
- And it disappeared from top Google Search results
This one small mistake by Google hits the publisher in a big way –
They lose traffic, trust, and even future rankings.
But wait – doesn’t Google say “E-E-A-T” matters?
Apparently not enough.
Here’s what actually happens when Google messes up canonical like this:
- Traffic drops (especially in important morning hours)
- Breaking stories don’t get seen
- Publisher loses topical authority
- SEO teams get blamed, even though it’s not their fault
- And during a core update? The site can get hit badly or even penalized
What can a publisher even do in this case?
Imagine this:
- You’re already struggling to get Google to index your stories on time
- Finally, it gets crawled – but Google thinks it’s copied
- It sets the canonical to a random site
- And your article disappears from Google
Even if you fix it 2 days later, the moment is gone.
The story is gone.
The traffic is gone.
The trust is gone.
What does Google really want?
You keep saying: “Write helpful, original content” we do that.
You say: “Build E-E-A-T” Indian publishers have done that for years.
Still, a porn site gets picked over a news brand?
This is not a one-time glitch.
This shows Google’s systems crawling, indexing, canonical setting are not ready for real-time news publishing. Especially in fast-paced markets like India.
What needs to change?
- Google should respect publisher authority when setting canonicals
- Scraper sites must be actively punished, not rewarded
- News crawl in India should be faster and smarter
- There must be a way to fix mistakes quickly, not wait for months
- And AI Mode or Search Updates shouldn’t destroy a site because of one backend error
So,
If Google truly supports quality journalism and factual content then stop treating Indian news like a side project.
Because if a porn site can copy your story and still get credit, then all the talk about AI, quality content, and helpful results means nothing.